The Misinterpretations of the 'Broken Generation' Frame in Adolescent Brain Science
When facing children's problematic behaviors, the diagnosis adults most readily turn to is 'smartphones.' Whether it's a drop in academic focus, appearing depressed, or a lack of empathy, all the blame often points to that small rectangular device. Even though I work in the tech industry and develop products, I sometimes wonder if we are using technology as an excuse to ignore the real nature of the problem.
In April 2025, neuroscientist Jennifer Pfeifer took to the stage at TEDxPortland to delve into this issue. Jennifer Pfeifer TED Talk. She defines adolescence not as ‘evidence of a broken generation’ but as an ‘opportunity for brains remodeling to adapt to a rapidly changing world.’ In this article, we will use the scientific data and insights from her lecture to reassess how Korean society views youth and discuss where our true focus should lie.
Contents
Why do we feel children are 'broken'?
Not laziness, but survival-driven time zone adaptation
Data that defies intuition: Smartphones vs. Parents
1. Why Do We Feel That Children Are 'Ruined'?
There has never been a time in history when the older generation did not worry about the next. In the past, it was rock music and TV that raised concerns, and now smartphones and social media have taken their place. Jennifer Pfeifer calls the tendency to label the young generation as anxious, depressed, and addicted, and to stigmatize them pessimistically, 'Doom-shaming'. Terms like 'teen syndrome' or 'annoying kid', or debates over kid-free zones that essentially bar children from entry, may be forms of doom-shaming that label children as immature outsiders.
The issue is that such stigmas do not stop at adult biases; they distort how adolescents view themselves. However, data from neuroscience disagrees with our intuition.
Scientifically, adolescence is a long journey from around age 10, when puberty begins, to 25, when one takes on adult social roles. During this period, the brain is not in a state of deficiency but is undergoing a massive reconstruction powered by remarkable plasticity to adapt to the environment.
Particularly intriguing is decision-making ability. We tend to believe adolescents are immature, but in a calm state of cold cognition, a 16-year-old adolescent makes rational judgments on par with adults APA Report. This data is crucial in discussions about voting rights or medical decision-making rights. Children are much more rational than we think. Perhaps it’s just that we haven’t given them 'time to think calmly' and 'an environment where they are respected'.
When we view children as 'geniuses of adaptation' rather than 'incomplete beings', the tone of the conversation changes.
2. Jet Lag Adaptation for Survival, Not Laziness
One of the most common conflicts reported by parents of teenagers is sleep issues. They say, "They stay up late doing nothing, and can't wake up in the morning." In Korea, this is often blamed on smartphone addiction or laziness, and children are scolded. However, Professor Pfeifer explains that this is a completely normal biological phenomenon.
Sleep Phase Delay: During adolescence, the release of melatonin, the hormone that induces sleep, is delayed by 1-2 hours.
Social Jetlag: Kids' bodies are set to sleep and wake up late, but school and extracurricular schedules force them to wake up at dawn.
It's akin to experiencing daily jet lag failure as if returning from an overseas trip. Especially for Korean teenagers, this biological change is compounded by physical sleep deprivation due to cram schools and night self-study sessions. Lack of sleep at a time when the brain is actively remodeling is like a construction site running out of materials. The child not waking up in the morning may not be rebellion, but rather a signal from their body trying to adapt.
This period of adolescence, their body may appear like an adult's (Adultification), but their brain and emotions still need protection. Particularly for early-maturing girls, the analysis reveals that their depression is more attributed to societal pressures to "act grown-up" because of their physical appearance, rather than the hormones themselves, which is significant for us to understand.
It's not laziness; their clock is simply ticking differently from ours.
3. Data Defying Intuition: Smartphones vs. Parents
So, is the evil of smartphones we are so convinced of really true? The meta-analysis presented by Professor Pfeifer is quite shocking.
Social Media and Depression: Excessive use only slightly increases the risk of depression from 20% to 23%. While the impact isn't negligible, it's too small a figure to blame for ruining a generation.
Bullying: It nearly doubles the risk of depression.
Mental Health of Caregivers: When parents are depressed or anxious, the child's risk surges by over 3.5 times.
We might be going to war over a 3% risk (smartphones) while possibly neglecting a 350% risk (care for parent's mental health). Smartphones might not be the cause but rather a marker, chosen as an escape by already troubled kids.
"Put your own oxygen mask on first." — Original Lecture by Jennifer Pfeifer
Like airplane safety rules, to save the child, the parent must first put on their own oxygen mask. Parents need to be happy and stable before they can share oxygen with their child. Instead of struggling to take away the child's smartphone, scientifically, it's more effective parenting to check first how much you've laughed today and whether your stress is being managed.
The most powerful parenting tool is not the latest tablet, but a parent's peaceful mind.
TL;DR
Doom-shaming refers to the phenomenon where older generations categorize the youth as an 'anxious, smartphone-addicted, broken generation.' Jennifer Pfeifer, a neuroscientist, highlights that such stigmatization actually hinders growth and emphasizes that data shows the teenage brain possesses high adaptability and resilience.
Adolescence is not a period of deficiency but rather a 'golden time for adaptation,' when brain plasticity is maximized.
Age 10-25: The period defined as adolescence by neuroscience is much longer than expected.
Cold Cognition: By the age of 16, rational decision-making is at an adult level Neuroscience consensus.
The 3.5 Factor: Parents' mental health has a significantly greater impact on children than smartphones (about 1.15 times increased risk).
Stop Doom-shaming: Instead of being pessimistic about kids, we should trust their adaptability and look after our own well-being first.
Rather than sighing at the smartphone in your child's hand right now, why not look into their eyes and take a moment to check your expression in a mirror? Children are stronger than we think, and we can have a larger impact than we realize.
EXTERNAL:
💰 60% OFF coupon for new users only Search 2HN43PU or 👉 Click the link to get started!
🌟 Already have a SHEIN account? You can still enjoy up to 40% OFF on top brands — just use code U74EGG2 on the SHEIN App or simply click here to grab your coupon 💕
